#9 Pizza Cottage (Pizza & Subs)
The Pizza Cottage building has had a long history of serving Pickaway County residents. Formerly a Ponderosa, Pizza Cottage is one of the most popular restaurants in Pickaway County, having the most reviews of any restaurant on our list – almost one in ten reviewers decided to rate this restaurant. It is one of the easiest restaurants to get visit, as its just off US-23 at Pickaway Crossing.
Average Rating: 4.35 / 5.00 with 821 reviews
The most recent reviews from Google say:
“One of my favorite pizza places. The loaded baked potato pizza is a delight! Friendly service and relaxed atmosphere”
“First time here. The pizza is phenomenal! & our waitress was great.”
“Really good pizza. Nice clean bar and dining room. Very friendly staff.”