CIRCLEVILLE, Ohio — For the Pitzer family, the Buffalo Wild Wings in Circleville has long been a favorite neighborhood spot. But following a major milestone, it became the centerpiece of a heartwarming, full-circle celebration years in the making.
The journey began in December 2023, when Nathan Pitzer and his wife, Caitlynn, received an urgent call from their agency, New Leaf in Circleville. Highland County Children’s Services was seeking an immediate placement for a 13-day-old newborn baby boy.
Hours later, Caitlynn pulled into the parking lot of the Circleville Buffalo Wild Wings to meet with the caseworkers. It was in that parking lot that the couple was first placed with the infant, whom they named Allan Ray.
“He gained our love and attention instantly, becoming one of us on day one,” Nathan Pitzer shared.
As Allan grew, he developed a habit of rapidly waving his arms at his sides whenever he got excited. Because of his unique gesture and the family’s frequent visits to the restaurant, they affectionately nicknamed him their “little chicken wing.”
The Pitzers remained dedicated regulars at the local establishment, noting that the restaurant’s low staff turnover and friendly team made it feel like a second home over the years.
On March 9, 2026, Allan Ray’s adoption was officially finalized. Looking to share the significance of the occasion, Nathan sent an email to the restaurant’s management team, outlining how Allan’s journey with their family had physically started in their parking lot.
The store’s general manager, Gary, responded immediately with a phone call. Before even knowing the final guest count, Gary offered to completely cover and donate the food for Allan’s upcoming adoption celebration.
For the party, the restaurant went above and beyond the family’s expectations, donating more than 1,000 boneless wings, potato wedges, fresh salad, and ranch dressing to feed the large gathering of supporters.
“The fact that Buffalo Wild Wings stepped up in this manner was beyond compassionate,” Pitzer said, praising Gary and his staff for their deep connection to the community. “They proved that they aren’t just a restaurant in Circleville—they are a vital part of the fabric of this town.”
By sharing Allan’s story, the Pitzer family hopes to not only shine a light on the generosity of local businesses but also inspire others by highlighting the profound beauty and impact of foster care and adoption.
