
CIRCLEVILLE, Ohio — A Circleville father is facing felony charges after allegedly blocking two males in his driveway and seizing a bag of THC cartridges when they showed up to sell the drugs to his son — raising the question for local residents: Did he cross the line into vigilante justice, or did he do what any parent would do to protect their child?
Joshua Scott was arrested Sunday night on charges of robbery and unlawful restraint following an investigation by the Pickaway County Sheriff’s Office.
According to the incident report, Deputy C. Kreager responded around 8:14 p.m. on Nov. 15 to a residence on Yankeetown Pike in Circleville for an assault complaint. There, the deputy met with Hunter Craig and his mother, Brittany Craig.
Hunter Craig had a bloody lip, red marks on his forehead, and dried blood on his sweatshirt, deputies noted. He told authorities that he and a friend had driven earlier that evening to sell THC cartridges to an acquaintance he had messaged on Snapchat.
Craig alleged that as soon as they pulled into the driveway, a truck blocked their van in. He claimed three men pounded on the vehicle’s windows, pulled both him and his friend out, beat them, and pulled guns on them before demanding he hand over what he had. Craig told deputies he turned over a black Adidas bag containing three to four THC cartridges, white Old Spice deodorant, a phone charger, and approximately $50 before a woman came outside and de-escalated the situation.
Mom of the child told investigators she had noticed earlier in the night that her son’s phone location was turned off. After she tried calling him without an answer, he called back to say something had happened and that he was on his way home.
Using recent destinations on Hunter Craig’s Apple Maps and county property records, investigators traced the incident to 6480 Brooks Miller Road in Circleville. Detective Carver responded to assist and inspected Craig’s van, noting smudges on the passenger-side window and small bits of broken glass on the passenger seat — which Craig said likely came from his friend’s broken phone — while the driver’s side window appeared untouched.
Deputies also interviewed the second male who had been in the van. He reported that a man with a firearm in his waistband assaulted him and broke his cellphone during the altercation, though he did not claim the weapon was pulled. He told deputies none of his property was taken and, with his legal guardian’s approval, declined to provide a written statement or be listed as a victim.
Detective Carver and Deputy Kreager then went to the Brooks Miller Road residence, where they spoke with a homeowner. She confirmed an incident had occurred and explained that she had confiscated her son’s phone earlier in the week after he got into trouble.
According to her, Craig sent a Snapchat message to her son’s account asking if he knew anyone who wanted to buy THC cartridges. She told deputies she replied through her son’s account that she would buy two and arranged for Craig to come to the house. When he arrived, she said, her husband, Joshua Scott, and his cousin confronted the pair about trying to sell drugs to their son, and Joshua Scott took the bag.
Joshua Scott later came outside and handed over the black bag containing the THC cartridges and deodorant to deputies. After being read his Miranda rights, Scott admitted to blocking Craig’s van in the driveway with his truck and grabbing onto Craig so he could not run, telling investigators he demanded the cartridges because he did not want Craig selling them to “other kids.”
Scott denied hitting Craig or pulling a gun, stating he only wanted to scare him and even helped Craig get his van started so he could leave. Deputies noted Scott smelled of alcohol, and he admitted to drinking two beers earlier while watching the Bengals game.
Scott was taken into custody on charges of robbery and unlawful restraint. Deputies photographed the THC cartridges and logged them into evidence before returning the bag and remaining personal items to Craig. No cash was found inside the bag, and Craig told deputies the $50 may not have been in there.








