#5 Dairy Shed
The Circleville Dairy Shed has been a long-standing institution of Circleville for many years. But its food and desserts have kept young and old alike coming back for more, as its the highest rated place for ice cream in Pickaway County. They offer a massive selection of both food and desserts with dozens of different flavors of soft serve, and soft serve-based concoctions. They’re closed a few weeks in the winter, but otherwise, serve up great treats year ’round. They also have a second location in Kingston.
Average Rating: 4.57 / 5.00 with 415 reviews
The most recent reviews from Google say:
“Awesome place! So much variety in soft serve. I will definitely be returning.”
“Dairy Shed is the Bomb. A little bit of everything. I have not had anything that was bad. Customer service is Awesome.”
“Nice small ice cream shop nice and excellent food and ice cream the pineapple upside is awesome”